Can a Child Get an OBC Certificate from Their Mother?

The Supreme Court of India is set to hear a significant case on July 22, 2025, that could redefine how caste certificates are issued to children of single mothers, especially those from the Other Backward Class (OBC) category. The matter questions current rules that prioritize paternal lineage over maternal caste identity, raising critical concerns under Article 14 (Right to Equality) and Article 21 (Right to Personal Liberty) of the Constitution.

What Is the Current Supreme Court Case About OBC Certificates for Children of Single Mothers?

On June 23, 2025, a division bench of Justices KV Viswanathan and N Kotiswar Singh heard a plea filed by a single mother who holds an OBC certificate, seeking a similar certificate for her child. The petitioner challenged the Delhi Revenue Department’s guidelines, which require OBC status to be verified through the father or paternal relatives.

The mother's contention is that such guidelines unfairly exclude single mothers from passing their caste identity to their children, thereby violating constitutional rights. She has asked the Court to frame or amend existing rules to ensure that a child can inherit the mother’s caste if she is the sole caregiver.

What Do the Existing Guidelines Say About Issuing OBC Certificates?

Currently, most state guidelines require a copy of an OBC certificate from the father or paternal blood relatives. These rules often ignore the mother's caste status, even in cases where the child is raised solely by her.

This framework places undue emphasis on patrilineal descent, leaving children of single, divorced, or widowed OBC mothers without valid access to caste-based entitlements, including reservation in education and employment.

Has the Supreme Court Addressed Caste Identity in Inter-Caste Marriages Before?

Yes, a landmark case often cited in such matters is the 2012 judgment in Rameshbhai Dabhai Naika vs. State of Gujarat. In that case, the Court examined whether a child born from an inter-caste marriage inherits the caste of the father or mother.

The Court ruled that while there may be a presumption of the child adopting the father's caste, especially if the father belongs to a forward caste, this is not a legal certainty. If the child is raised solely by the mother who belongs to a Scheduled Caste (SC) or Scheduled Tribe (ST) and faces social disadvantages, they may be allowed to claim her caste.

This ruling opened the door to recognizing lived experience and social environment over just biological descent.

How Have High Courts Ruled in Similar Cases Involving Maternal Caste Inheritance?

Different High Courts have taken varying positions depending on case specifics. Two important judgments:

1. Rumy Chowdhury v. Department of Revenue, Delhi (2019 & 2020)

In this case, a single mother from the SC community, serving in the Indian Air Force, sought caste certificates for her sons. The Delhi government rejected her application because her husband was from a forward caste, and the guidelines prioritized paternal lineage.

The Delhi High Court upheld the rejection, stating that unless the children faced disadvantages due to their mother's caste or lived in deprived conditions, granting them a caste certificate could misuse reservation benefits meant for more underprivileged individuals.

2. Smti. Moonsoon Barkakoti v. State of Assam (2024)

In contrast, the Gauhati High Court ruled in favor of a woman who had inherited her OBC status from her mother, despite her father being from the general category. The court found that she had been raised within her mother’s community and faced social disadvantages. Her claim was upheld because her lived experience aligned with her mother’s caste identity.

What Is the Central Legal Question in This Supreme Court Case?

The primary question is: Can a child inherit OBC status from the mother, especially when she is the sole caregiver and belongs to an OBC community?

The case seeks to update caste certification rules that are currently outdated and discriminatory, particularly against women-headed households. The verdict could influence how caste identity is viewed in single-parent or inter-caste family structures and may set new constitutional standards for gender and caste equality.

Why Is This Case Important for Gender Justice and Constitutional Equality?

This case goes beyond administrative policy—it touches on gender equality, child rights, and caste-based social justice. By challenging the male-centric view of caste inheritance, the petitioner is advocating for a system where single mothers are not penalized due to outdated norms.

If the Supreme Court allows maternal caste inheritance in such cases, it will be a progressive step towards recognizing women’s independent legal and social identity, especially for those who raise children alone.

What Could the Supreme Court Decide on July 22, 2025?

While the final verdict will depend on the arguments and precedents presented, the Court may:

• Recommend new guidelines that allow caste certificates based on the mother’s identity in cases of single parenthood.

• Clarify the use of "lived experience" and "community integration" as valid factors in caste determination.

• Reinforce or revise previous rulings like Rameshbhai Dabhai Naika to reflect modern family structures.

Whatever the outcome, this case could have a long-term impact on how caste identity is legally determined in India—especially for children of single mothers, divorced women, and widows.

Explore more on UPSC Content

Click for Daily Quotes:

Stay updated with the latest news by joining our Telegram channel – The PRESS Pad , and follow us on Instagram and X.